Motivating People (and the Faster Ways to Demotivate Them)

Two women in discussion at a desk

~by Haley Lynn Gray~

Motivating people is one of the harder parts of both parenting and leading, and the two turn out to require the same skills — with one important difference: your employees can leave.

Here’s what actually works, and what reliably doesn’t.

Start by finding out what they want

Not what you’d want in their position. What they want.

Recognition, autonomy, money, security, learning, flexibility, a promotion, or simply to be left alone to do good work. People will usually tell you if you ask — and almost nobody has ever asked them.

Managing everyone the way you’d like to be managed is the commonest mistake there is.

What motivates

Progress people can see. The single most reliable motivator. Show what’s moved, especially on long projects where it’s easy to feel nothing is happening.

Ownership of something real. Not a task — an outcome, with the authority to make decisions about it.

Specific praise. “You handled that furious client beautifully on Tuesday” beats “good job” by an enormous margin, and it teaches people exactly what to repeat.

Knowing why it matters. Most employees never find out what happened downstream of their work.

And being paid properly. Money won’t motivate excellence on its own, but underpayment reliably destroys it — no amount of culture survives someone discovering they’re worth more elsewhere.

What demotivates, and it’s easier than motivating

This is worth saying plainly: it takes far less effort to demotivate someone than to inspire them. Careless words do it in seconds.

Tolerating poor performance from someone else. Nothing demoralises good people faster than watching someone get away with it.

Taking credit for their work. Once. That’s all it takes.

Micromanaging after delegating. It tells people you don’t trust them, and they respond by not deciding anything.

Moving the goalposts. Changing what success means after the work has started.

Criticising in public. The single most expensive thirty seconds available to a manager.

Being unpredictable. If people can’t tell which version of you they’ll get, they’ll stop bringing you anything — and the problems you hear about late are the expensive ones.

And ignoring good work entirely. Silence is a message. People conclude it wasn’t noticed, and calibrate accordingly.

The parenting comparison, honestly

With children you’re building judgement over years, and you can insist. With employees you’re renting capability from adults who chose to be there and can leave on a fortnight’s notice.

Which makes the workplace version harder, not easier — and means the influence has to be earned rather than assumed.

Find out what they want. Give them something real to own. Notice the work out loud. And avoid the seven things above, which cost nothing to avoid and a great deal to do.

If this resonates, you don’t have to figure it out alone.
We host small, thoughtful Round Table conversations inside Women’s Entrepreneur Network where women leaders talk through exactly this kind of challenge.
You’re welcome to join us.

Related Posts

What to Do When You’re Stuck in Analysis Paralysis

What to Do When You’re Stuck in Analysis Paralysis

Analysis paralysis is rarely an information problem. People stuck on a decision usually have plenty of information — frequently more than they need. What they don't have is a rule for when to stop looking. The idea that fixes this Herbert Simon, who won the...

Decision Fatigue: What’s Real and What Isn’t

Decision Fatigue: What’s Real and What Isn’t

By four in the afternoon, decisions you'd have made carefully at nine get made carelessly, or not at all. Most people who run something recognise this immediately. The usual explanation for it is wrong, or at least much shakier than it's presented. Which matters,...

When to Trust Your Gut, and When Not To

When to Trust Your Gut, and When Not To

"Trust your gut" and "don't make emotional decisions" are both standard advice, and they contradict each other. Neither tells you which situation you're in. There's a good answer to that, and it comes from an unusual source. Two researchers who expected to disagree...

Why “Busy” Is a Red Flag: Identifying Unhealthy Priorities

Why “Busy” Is a Red Flag: Identifying Unhealthy Priorities

Ask a business owner how things are going and the most common answer is "busy." It functions as good news. It signals demand, momentum, a business that people want. Nobody follows up. Which is convenient, because busy tells you nothing about whether the business is...

How to Stop Feeling Behind All the Time

How to Stop Feeling Behind All the Time

Behind what? It's worth actually answering, because the feeling of being behind requires a schedule — and there isn't one. Nobody issued a timetable for how large your business should be by now, or what you should be earning in year four, or when you were...

Rest Is a Leadership Skill

Rest Is a Leadership Skill

Rest gets filed under self-care, which is why owners ignore it. Self-care sounds like something you do when there's spare capacity, and there is never spare capacity. Try a different frame. Your judgement is the product. Not your hours — your judgement. Pricing,...

Find what you need

Lead Your Team

Delegation, hiring, difficult conversations, and becoming the boss you'd want to work for.

Build the Business

Pricing, launching, systems, and building something that doesn't depend on you.

Women in Leadership

Negotiation, the pay gap, and what the research actually says about women who lead.

Get Seen

Being visible without the cringe — podcasts, content, and being remembered.

Lead Yourself

Courage, your inner critic, time, and protecting what matters most.

You're Not Alone

The loneliness of leading, and why the best owners don't solve everything alone.